Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Our Personal Lenses (or, My Brain Hurts)

There are certain things that make little to no sense to me.  Earlier in life, I would rather snarkily remark on evidence and how I couldn't BELIEVE people don't GET certain things.  With age comes perspective, or at least a modicum of self-control, and I now remind myself that I see things through the lens of scientific training.  Many people don't, and why should they?  We all see the world through our most relevant lens.  

This post is about vaccine deniers, because another article was recently published that shatters my lens.  The latest study is described here by the Washington Post, and the body of work is described here in "Dartmouth Now".  The original articles were published in the peer-reviewed journals Pediatrics and Vaccine.  The gist of this line of research is that providing evidence of both vaccine efficacy AND lack of harmful effects actually backfires.  In other words, when presented with solid, valid reasons why vaccinating a child against whooping cough will a.) cause her no harm; and b.) protect her from very severe harm (or death), a parent with a preexisting belief is LESS likely to utilize the intervention.  Uh...excuse me?  Scientific training or none, that is absurd.  A parent would rather be right than protect their child?  It makes no sense to me whatsoever.

Part of this stems, of course, from the (mis)perception that the safety and efficacy of vaccines are debatable.  They are not.  Individuals with the appropriate background and training are pretty much in lockstep on this issue.  Are there poorly efficacious vaccines?  Of course.  The BCG/tuberculosis vaccines (not used here in the US) has sub-par at best efficacy.  Are there vaccines with poor side effect profiles?  Yes.  The Y19/yellow fever vaccines is terribly painful, and gifted me with quite the high fever for a day.  Neither of these are standard, because some pretty experienced people have weighed the costs and benefits and decided against it.  Those that ARE standard recommendations for children, though, are so for some very good reasons.  As a parent I often see posts on message boards with questions about vaccines or vaccines schedules by someone genuinely seeking information, and often they give the caveat that they are "not trying to start a debate".  I appreciate the desire for information without wanting to engender hostility, and resent that these parents are forced to think about taking care not to.  I especially resent it because, as mentioned, this is not a debatable issue if one operates in the realm of reality.  Apparently, however, the more reality one tries to interject, the less effective that reality is.  If I'm being polite, this is counterintuitive.  If I'm being kinesthetic, I'm torn between *facepalm* and *headdesk*.    If I'm being realistic... my brain hurts.


 

                                            VS.

2 comments:

  1. "Part of this stems, of course, from the (mis)perception that the safety and efficacy of vaccines are debatable. They are not. " Are u kidding? This is extreme to say the least. Since when did Vaccines become a religion.......oh........Why don't you anywhere address the concerns of safety. The ingredients in vaccines, the toxicity on the body, none of them have been tested for carcinogenic, mutogenic or infertility potential, btw. Not to mention the thousands of cases of VAERS (only approx 10% reported) vaccine injured and real life parents that can testify to that. Many more children die from adverse effects of the MMR vaccine than from measles in the U.S. In fact in U.S and other developed countries there is barely a death a year from measles - if that. If you are so concerned about vaccine compliance, why don't you and whoever you are working for devote more time to studying ways you can make vaccines safer. Or is pushing out propaganda an easier strategy in your mind? Are you getting paid for this nonsense? It's the only thing that I can conclude, as surely you cannot be this ignorant and close-minded. Surely.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My name is hoover, my 18 years old daughter, Tricia was diagnosed of herpes 3 years ago. ever since then,we have been going from one hospital to the other. We tried all sorts of pills but all efforts to get rid of the virus was futile. The blisters kept on reappearing after some months. My daughter was making use of Acyclovir tablets 200mg. 2 tablets every 6hours and fusitin cream 15grams. and H5 POT. Permanganate with water to be applied 2x a day but all still show no result. So I was on the internet some months back, to sought for any other means of saving my only child. just then, i came across a comment on dr imoloa herbal treatment and decided to give it a try. i contacted the him and he prepared some herbs and sent it to me together with guidelines on how to use the herbs through DHL courier service. my daughter used it as directed dr imoloa and in less than 14days, my daughter regained her health.. You should contact Dr imoloa today directly on his email address for any kind of health challenge; lupus disease,  mouth ulcer,  mouth cancer, body pain, fever, hepatitis A.B.C.,   syphilis,  diarrhea,  HIV/AIDS,  Huntington's Disease,   back acne,  Chronic renal failure,   addison disease,  Chronic Pain,   Crohn's Disease,   Cystic Fibrosis,  Fibromyalgia,   Inflammatory Bowel Disease,  fungal nail disease, Lyme Disease, Celia disease, Lymphoma, Major Depression,  Malignant Melanoma,   Mania,  Melorheostosis,   Meniere's Disease,  Mucopolysaccharidosis , Multiple Sclerosis,  Muscular Dystrophy,  Rheumatoid Arthritis, Alzheimer's Disease, parkison disease, vaginal cancer, epilepsy,  Anxiety Disorders, Autoimmune Disease,   Back Pain,  Back Sprain,   Bipolar Disorder,  Brain Tumour,  Malignant,   Bruxism, Bulimia,  Cervical Disk Disease, cardiovascular disease, Neoplasms, chronic respiratory disease,  mental and behavioural disorder,     Cystic Fibrosis,   Hypertension, Diabetes, asthma,  Inflammatory autoimmune-mediated arthritis.  chronic kidney disease, inflammatory joint disease,  impotence,  feta alcohol spectrum,  Dysthymic Disorder,   Eczema, tuberculosis,  Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, constipation, inflammatory bowel disease.  and many more; contact him on email- drimolaherbalmademedicine@gmail.com./ also on  whatssap-+2347081986098.

    ReplyDelete